Is Jalen Hurts overrated? Examining the hype vs. reality of the Eagles' star QB

Jalen Hurts has undeniably become one of the most electrifying quarterbacks in the NFL. Leading the Philadelphia Eagles to a Super Bowl appearance, securing a massive $255 million contract, and displaying his dual-threat ability have all contributed to his rising stardom. However, critics argue that Hurts' success is more about the team around him than his individual greatness. So, is Jalen Hurts truly an elite quarterback, or is he simply benefitting from the perfect situation? Let's break it down.


One of the biggest arguments against Hurts being an elite quarterback is the team he has around him. The Eagles boast one of the best offensive lines in the league, anchored by stars like Jason Kelce and Lane Johnson. This protection gives Hurts the time to make decisions, something many other quarterbacks don’t have the luxury of.
Additionally, the Eagles' offense is stacked with talent. With weapons like A.J. Brown, DeVonta Smith, and Dallas Goedert, Hurts has a receiving corps that many quarterbacks would dream of. His running game is also elite, with a strong backfield that takes pressure off him to carry the offense alone. The question remains—how much of his success is Hurts' individual talent versus the talent around him?


Hurts has put up solid numbers, but when compared to the league’s top passers like Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Joe Burrow, some gaps emerge. His accuracy, while improved, isn’t in the top tier of quarterbacks. Critics point to his struggles when forced into pure passing situations, particularly when his running ability is limited.
While the debate over Hurts' skill level continues, one thing is undeniable—his leadership. Hurts is known for his incredible work ethic, calm demeanor under pressure, and the ability to inspire his teammates. Even if his numbers don’t always match the best in the league, his leadership and clutch performances keep him in the conversation as a top-tier quarterback.
Also Read: NFL owners set to vote on Green Bay Packers' push to ban Eagles’ ‘Tush Push’ play, sparking major controversy
Hurts may not be the most naturally gifted passer in the NFL, but his ability to win, combined with his leadership, makes him invaluable. Is he benefiting from a great system? Absolutely. But does that mean he’s overrated? Not necessarily. His talent, work ethic, and leadership prove he belongs in the conversation of top quarterbacks—even if some still have doubts.